Masquerade NYC guide: 5 things to know before attending

Andrew Lloyd Webber’s “Phantom of the Opera” has been one of the defining icons of musical theater since its debut in the 1980s, boasting the longest-running production in Broadway history before ending its run in 2023. But the Phantom didn’t stay away from New York City for long, returning in the form of “Masquerade,” an immersive off-Broadway experience that debuted in 2025.

As a huge fan of immersive theater and interacting with characters, I had wanted to make the trip to see the show ever since its marketing campaign began. Hidden hints and letters were distributed by characters around New York, teasing the Phantom’s return and culminating with a select few being invited into what would become the show’s home, where they encountered the Phantom himself. When Attractions Magazine was recently invited to experience the production, I immediately booked our flight and jumped at the chance.

If you’ve already decided to attend “Masquerade,” here are five things you’ll want to know before stepping inside the Opera Populaire.

And if you’re undecided, you can read our review of Masquerade.

1. What is the Masquerade dress code?

There’s a dress code, and as the show’s title implies, masks are required.

Formal attire is strongly encouraged, and the only colors guests are permitted to wear are black, white, or silver, including masks. Just don’t wear one that resembles the Phantom’s signature look.

If you don’t bring your own mask, a lace, glasses-compatible version will be provided as a souvenir. If you arrive wearing other colors, staff may provide a black cloak to wear over your clothing, though supplies are limited and may not always be available. To fully embrace the atmosphere and avoid any surprises, it’s best to come prepared.

2. Be prepared to spend most of the evening on your feet

Comfortable shoes are a must. The experience unfolds across multiple floors as guests wind their way above and below the opera house. While some scenes include opportunities to sit, expect to spend the majority of the evening standing and moving from space to space.

During our visit, I noticed staff members assisting a guest along an alternate route through the venue, suggesting that accommodations are available for those who may need them. If accessibility is a concern, it’s worth reaching out to the venue ahead of your visit to discuss available options.

3. Arrive early and pay attention to the details

Part of the magic of “Masquerade” begins before the story officially starts.

From entering through the storefront disguised as Lee’s Art Shop to taking in the elaborate details scattered throughout the Opera Populaire, the experience rewards guests who slow down and look closely. Give yourself extra time before your scheduled entry to check in, admire the environment, and settle into the atmosphere before you’re swept into the evening’s events.

4. Do you have to participate?

Participation is encouraged, but it isn’t required.

As someone who enjoys interacting with performers, I embraced those moments whenever they arose. My husband, on the other hand, preferred observing from the sidelines. We both walked away feeling like the experience struck the right balance.

Guests are guided through the evening and occasionally invited to engage with performers, but there’s never pressure to do more than you’re comfortable with. You’ll likely have just as much fun watching everything unfold as you will becoming part of the action.

Plus, as you enter, you’re offered a glass of champagne to help settle into the evening. A non-alcoholic option is also available.

5. How does the “pulse” system work?

One of the most fascinating aspects of “Masquerade” is its rotating “pulse” system.

Multiple versions of the story unfold simultaneously throughout the building, with performers moving between groups and even switching roles throughout the evening.

For example, if you’re part of a 7:45 p.m. entry group, the actor playing Meg in your experience could be portraying Christine for the guests entering behind you at 8 p.m. While the intricacies of the system remain part of the production’s magic, it’s worth keeping an eye on cast members’ social media accounts or asking when purchasing tickets if you have a favorite performer you’d like to see.

At the conclusion of the show, guests gather at Nocturne, the Phantom’s underground lake transformed into an atmospheric cocktail lounge. The venue is also open for a limited time to the public after performances conclude, allowing visitors to purchase merchandise, enjoy a drink, and, if luck is on their side, encounter members of the cast.

“Masquerade” is located at 218 W. 57th St. in New York City, disguised as “Lee’s Art Shop,” and is currently booking through the end of 2026. Tickets are available at masqueradenyc.com.

The featured image of this article includes a photo from Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman.

More Attractions Magazine stories